Group seeks order for more school construction funds

Lawyers ask the top court to force state to finish projects put on hold
Friday, August 12, 2005 • BY STEVE CHAMBERS • Star-Ledger Staff

Lawyers for the state's poorest children yesterday asked the New Jersey Supreme Court to order more funding for a $6 billion school construction fund that has nearly run out of cash.

The action by the Education Law Center in Newark came just two weeks after the Schools Construction Corp. -- which is overseeing the program -- announced it was putting more than 200 school projects on hold because it didn't have the money to build them.

The SCC has been beset by allegations of waste and mismanagement since it announced it was running low on funds and could build less than half the schools needed by the state's poorest 31 districts. Acting on a long-standing suit by the law center, the Supreme Court ordered the state in 1998 to replace "crumbling and obsolescent" schools in the poorest districts.

The law center asked the court to order more money because it said state education officials were failing to respond to the huge shortfall.

"We really felt compelled to go to the court," said David Sciarra, executive director of the law center. "Everyone knows we have a problem. At the end of the day, more resources are required, and yet we've had no action."

But Republican legislators, already outraged by the SCC debacle, said it was premature to make demands.

"For them to disregard the mismanagement or misuse of funds, it's obvious their agenda has nothing to do with what is right," said Assemblyman Joseph Malone (R- Burlington), a member of both the education and budget committees. "It's a disgusting grab for taxpayer money regardless of how that money is spent."

The law center and some of its supporters in the Legislature argue, however, that allowing the program to grind to a halt will cost the public even more money. In legal papers filed yesterday, the law center estimated that every year of delay could cost the state $40 million to $60 million in additional funds. It argues the 1998 court order means every pending school must eventually be built.

The state is in the process of determining precisely how many schools are needed in the 31 "special needs" districts, but in its filing, the law center identifies 103 schools that it claims are far enough along that halting work will cost the state money.

On July 27, SCC officials voted to proceed with 59 school projects they said they could afford to build. At the time, they said 207 other projects would be put on hold, but did not release a full list.

Both the SCC and the state Department of Education declined to comment on the lawsuit. A spokeswoman for acting Gov. Richard J. Codey also declined to comment, but Codey has said the debate over more funding should wait until a new governor and Legislature are elected in November.

The SCC has been under fire since a February Star-Ledger article revealed its schools were costing far more to build than ones overseen by local districts. That spurred a review by the state inspector general, which concluded in April that the SCC was riddled with inefficiencies and lax controls that opened the door to widespread waste and abuse.


Steve Chambers may be reached at schambers@starledger.com or (973) 392-1674.
© 2005 The Star-Ledger. Used by NJ.com with permission.

Return to Articles page